TrainWeb.org Facebook Page

Saniwax Paper Company, Complainant, vs. The Ann Arbor Railroad Company, et al., Defendants. D-2519. March 12, 1932.

BY THE COMMISSION: Complainant is a corporation manufacturing waxed paper and by complaint filed February 5th, 1930, it is alleged that the second class rates collected or sought to be collected on less than carload shipments on printed waxed paper wrappers originating at Kalamazoo, Michigan, and delivered to many Michigan destinations were unreasonable to the extent that they exceeded the third class rates. We are asked to require waiver of the collection of undercharges.

This proceeding was jointly heard with an Examiner for the Inter state Commerce Commission before whom a similar complaint involving interstate traffic was pending. On December 16th, 1931, the Interstate Commerce Commission issued its report and findings in I. C. C. Docket No. 23193, Saniwax Paper Co. vs. The Ann Arbor Railroad Company, et al. The report of the Interstate Commerce Commission referred to will hereinafter be called the “interstate report.” -

Complainant manufactures and ships waxed wrapping papers in continuous rolls and in sheets, cut to size, from Kalamazoo to many destinations in Michigan. When this article is shipped in continuous rolls, the commodity is classified as “waxed wrapping paper” and is rated at third class. When transported in sheets, cut to size, it is classified as “waxed paper wrappers,” and prior to January 20th, 1930, was rated second class. On that date defendants voluntarily established the present third class rating on waxed paper wrappers

The events leading up to the filing of this complaint with this Com mission as well as the Interstate Commerce Commission is detailed in the interstate report and will not be reiterated here, except that it may be stated that complainant did not file with this Commission a com plaint similar to that filed with the Interstate Commerce Commission in October, 1929, and designated as I. C. C. Docket No. 22815. Complainant, in asking this Commission to require waiver of undercharges is, stated differently, really asking this Commission to find that the rates legally applicable during the statutory period were unreasonable to the extent that they exceeded those subsequently and voluntarily made effective. The Interstate Commerce Commission has found insofar as the inter state rates were concerned that they were not unreasonable and there is no evidence of record whereby this Commission can find otherwise insofar as intrastate rates were concerned. - The complaint will be dismissed. An appropriate order will be entered. MICHIGAN PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION.

Saniwax Paper Company, Complainant, vs. The Ann Arbor Railroad Company, et al., Defendants. D-2519. March 12, 1932

This case being at issue upon complaint, and answers and briefs on file, and having been duly heard and submitted by the parties and full investigation of the things involved having been had and the Commission having on the date hereof made and filed its opinion containing its finding of fact and conclusions thereon, which said opinion is hereby referred to and made a part hereof;

Now, THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, That the complaint in this proceeding be and it is hereby dismissed. MICHIGAN PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION

Michigan Elevator Exchange, Inc., Complainant, vs. The Ann Arbor Rail road Company, (Walter S. Franklin and Frank C. Nicodemus, Jr., Receivers), The Michigan Central Railroad Company, (The New York Central Railroad Company, Lessee) Defendants. Informal Docket No. 390. April 1, 1932

This matter is before the Commission upon application of the above named defendants requesting that we authorize the payment of Fifty Dollars and Twenty-nine Cents ($50.29) to the above named complain ant as reparation in connection with the movement of two (2) carloads of bulk wheat moving from Ithaca, Michigan, to Battle Creek, Michigan, shipments being delivered on May 15 and 21, 1931.

At the time shipments moved the rate legally applicable upon wheat, carloads, from Ithaca, Michigan, to Battle Creek, Michigan, was the sixth class rate of Seventeen and One-half Cents (171% c) per hundred pounds. There was contemporaneously in effect via another route a lower rate of Fourteen and One-half Cents (14%.c) per hundred pounds, effective from Paines, Michigan, to Battle Creek, Michigan. Ithaca being intermediate from Paines, this rate would necessarily apply via the other route. When this condition was called to the attention of defend ants they immediately published a rate of Fourteen and One-half Cents (14.1%.c) per hundred pounds via route of movements, effective July 5th, 1931, and it is upon this basis that reparation is sought.

We find, after due consideration of all of the facts submitted in the pleadings and record, that the charges assessed were unreasonable to the extent that they exceed those collectible under a rate of Fourteen and One-half Cents (14.1%.c) per hundred pounds upon the commodity here at issue moving from Ithaca, Michigan, to Battle Creek, Michigan; that complainant paid and bore the charges upon the shipments in question; that complainant has been damaged to the extent of the difference be tween the charges paid and those that would have accrued at the rate herein found reasonable; and that it is entitled to reparation in the sum of Fifty Dollars and Twenty-nine Cents ($50.29), without interest.

Now, THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, That The Ann Arbor Railroad Company, Walter S. Franklin and Frank C. Nicodemus, Jr., Receivers, and The Michigan Central Railroad Company (The New York Central Railroad Company, Lessee), be and they are hereby authorized and directed to pay, jointly, as each participated in the traffic, to the above named complainant, Michigan Elevator Exchange, Inc., of Lansing, Michigan, on or before June 1st, 1932, the sum of Fifty Dollars and Twenty-nine Cents ($50.29), without interest, as reparation on account of the unreasonable charges collected on the above involved shipments. MICHI IGAN PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION.

Ludington Daily News April 3, 1932

COMMISSION MAY APPROVE MUSKEGON CARFERRY SERVICE

Pere Marquette Expected to Join Ann Arbor Railway in Opposing Move

MUSKEGON, Mich., April 2 – (AP) – Developments in the case of the Pennsylvania and Grand Trunk railroad for establishment of joint carferry service across Lake Michigan may result in its approval by the interstate commerce commission it was revealed here today.

It was indicated by officials of the roads they will modify their applications so as to eliminate Manitowoc as a Wisconsin terminal.

Principal opposition to the plan as indicated in objections filed by the Ann Arbor railroad was directed against the proposed Muskegon to Manitowoc operation. The Pere Marquette railroad also was expected to intervene. Both the Ann Arbor and Pere Marquette now operate car ferries from Western Michigan ports to Manitowoc.

Basic Dolomite, Incorporated, et al., Complainants, vs. The Ann Arbor Railroad Company, et al., Defendants. D-2702. April 29, 1932

Upon consideration of the application filed by the Koenig Coal & Supply Company on April 28th, 1932, for leave to intervene in the above entitled proceedings;

Now, THEREFORE, it is HEREBY ORDERED, That the Koenig Coal & Supply Company be and it is hereby permitted to intervene and be treated as a party hereto, with the right to have notice of and appear at the taking of testimony, produce and cross-examine witnesses, and be heard in brief or on oral argument, if oral argument is heard; provided, however, that the permission to intervene herein granted shall not be construed to allow intervenor to introduce evidence which will unduly broaden the issues raised in this proceeding.

It is FURTHER ORDERED, That a copy of this order be served upon parties in interest. MICHIGAN PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION.

Basic Dolomite, Incorporated, et al., Complainants, vs. The Ann Arbor Railroad Company, et al., Defendants. D-2702. May 17, 1932

Upon consideration of the application filed by the Ward Sand and Gravel Company on May 9th, 1932, for leave to intervene in the above entitled proceedings;

Now, THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, That the Ward Sand and Gravel Company be and it is hereby permitted to intervene and be treated as a party hereto, with the right to have notice of and appear at the taking of testimony, produce and cross-examine witnesses, and be heard in brief or on oral argument, if oral argument is heard; provided however, that the permission to intervene herein granted shall not be construed to allow intervenor to introduce evidence which will unduly broaden the issues raised in this proceeding.

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, That a copy of this order be served upon parties in interest. MICHIGAN PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION.

Basic Dolomite, Incorporated, et al., Complainants, vs. The Ann Arbor Railroad Company, et al., Defendants. D-2702. June 4, 1932

Upon consideration of the application filed by the Inland Lime and Stone Company on June 3rd, 1932, for leave to intervene in the above entitled proceedings;

Now, THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, That the Inland Lime and Stone Company be and it is hereby permitted to intervene and be treated as a party hereto, with the right to have notice of and appear at the taking of testimony, produce and cross-examine witnesses, and be heard in brief or on oral argument, if oral argument is heard, provided, how ever, that the permission to intervene herein granted shall not be construed to allow intervenor to introduce evidence which will unduly broaden the issues raised in this proceeding.

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, That a copy of this order be served upon parties in interest. MICHIGAN PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION.

Basic Dolomite, Incorporated, et al., Complainants, vs. The Ann Arbor Railroad Company, et al., Defendants. D-2702. June 8, 1932.

Upon consideration of the application filed by the Michigan Sand and Gravel Producers' Association on June 8th, 1932, for leave to intervene in the above entitled proceedings;

Now, THEREFORE, IT is HEREBY ORDERED, That the Michigan Sand and Gravel Producers' Association be and it is hereby permitted to intervene and be treated as a party hereto, with the right to have notice of and appear at the taking of testimony, produce and cross-examine witnesses, and be heard in brief or on oral argument, if oral argument is heard; provided, however, that the permission to intervene herein granted shall not be construed to allow intervenor to introduce evidence which will unduly broaden the issues raised in this proceeding.
It is FURTHER ORDERED, That a copy of this order be served upon parties in interest. MICHIGAN PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION

Basic Dolomite, Incorporated, et al., Complainants, vs. The Ann Arbor Railroad Company, et al., Defendants. D-2702. June 21, 1932.

Upon consideration of the application filed by The National Lime & Stone Company on June 17th, 1932, for leave to intervene in the above entitled proceedings;

Now, THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, That The National Lime & Stone Company be and it is hereby permitted to intervene and be treated as a party hereto, with the right to have notice of and appear at the taking of testimony, produce and cross-examine witnesses, and be heard in brief or on oral argument, if oral argument is heard; provided, how ever, that the permission to intervene herein granted shall not be construed to allow intervenor to introduce evidence which will unduly broaden the issues raised in this proceeding.

It is FURTHER ORDERED, That a copy of this order be served upon parties in interest. MICHIGAN PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION.

Basic Dolomite, Incorporated, et al., Complainants, vs. The Ann Arbor Railroad Company, et al., Defendants. D-2702. June 27, 1932.

Upon consideration of the application filed by the American Aggregates Corporation on June 23rd, 1932, for leave to intervene in the above entitled proceedings;

Now, THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY ORDER:ED, That the American Aggregates Corporation be and it is hereby permitted to intervene and be treated as a party hereto, with the right to have notice of and appear at the taking of testimony, produce and cross-examine witnesses, and be heard in brief or on oral argument, if oral argument is heard; provided, however that the permission to intervene herein granted shall not be construed to allow intervenor to introduce evidence which will unduly broaden the issues raised in this proceeding. -

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, That a copy of this order be served upon parties in interest. MICHIGAN PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION.

Cadillac Malleable Iron Company, Complainant, vs. Pere Marquette Rail way Company, The Ann Arbor Railroad Company, (Walter S. Franklin and Frank C. Nicodemus, Jr., Receivers) Defendants. Informal Docket No. 399. July 23, 1932. Cadillac Malleable Iron Company, Complainant, vs. Pere Marquette Rail way Company, The Ann Arbor Railroad Company, (Walter S. Franklin and Frank C. Nicodemus, Jr., Receivers) Defendants. Informal Docket No. 399. July 23, 1932. Cadillac Malleable Iron Company, Complainant, vs. Pere Marquette Rail way Company, The Ann Arbor Railroad Company, (Walter S. Franklin and Frank C. Nicodemus, Jr., Receivers) Defendants. Informal Docket No. 399. July 23, 1932.

This matter is before the Commission upon application of the above named defendants requesting that we authorize the payment of One Hundred Thirty-six Dollars and Three Cents ($136.03) to the above named complainant as reparation in connection with the movement of one (1) carload of core sand moving from Juniata, Michigan, to Cadillac, Michigan, shipment being delivered on October 1st, 1931.

At the time shipment moved the rate legally applicable on core sand was 19C per hundred pounds, minimum weight 40,000 pounds, from Juniata, Michigan, to Cadillac, Michigan, via route of movement. This rate was the sixth class rate and would have to be used for the reason that there was no commodity rate published. Core sand in carloads is ordinarily moved on low commodity rates, therefore, effective Feb ruary 16th, 1932, defendants published a rate of $1.51 per ton, minimum weight 90% of marked capacity of car, and it is upon this basis that reparation is sought.

We find, after due consideration of all of the facts submitted in the pleadings and records, that the charges assessed were unreasonable to the extent that they exceed those collectible under a rate of One Dollar and Fifty-one Cents ($1.51) per ton upon the commodity here at issue moving from Juniata, Michigan, to Cadillac, Michigan; that complain ant paid and bore the charges upon the shipment in question; that complainant has been damaged to the extent of the difference between the charges paid and those that would have accrued at the rate herein found reasonable; and that it is entitled to reparation in the sum of One Hundred Thirty-six Dollars and Three Cents ($136,03), without interest

Now, THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, That the Pere Marquette Rail way Company and The Ann Arbor Railroad Company (Walter S. Franklin and Frank C. Nicodemus, Jr., Receivers) be and they are hereby authorized and directed to pay, jointly, as each participated in the traffic, to the above named complainant, Cadillac Malleable Iron Company, of Cadillac, Michigan, on or before September 1st, 1932, the sum of One Hundred Thirty-six Dollars and Three Cents ($136.03), without interest, as reparation on account of the unreasonable charges collected on the above involved shipment. MICHIGAN PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION.

In the matter of the application of the Ann Arbor Railroad Company for permission to discontinue the towerman at the crossing of the tracks of the Ann Arbor Railroad Company and the New York Central Rail road Company at Federman. D-2739. October 10, 1932 In the matter of the application of the Ann Arbor Railroad Company for permission to discontinue the towerman at the crossing of the tracks of the Ann Arbor Railroad Company and the New York Central Rail road Company at Federman. D-2739. October 10, 1932

Application having been filed with the Commission by the Receivers of the Ann Arbor Railroad Company, under date of July 27, 1932 for permission to discontinue the towerman located at the crossing of its tracks and the tracks of the New York Central Railroad Company at Federman for the reason that few trains are operated over the crossing. The Commission being further advised in said application that if granted permission to discontinue the said towerman, it is agreeable to the Ann Arbor Railroad Company and the New York Central Railroad Company that the signals at said crossing shall be set normally clear for all train movements over the crossing on the Ann Arbor and remain thus, except when a New York Central train is to use the crossing, in which case one of the train crew will go to the tower and operate the signals, setting the route clear for train movements on the New York Central and at block against train movements on the Ann Arbor Railroad, and as soon as the train movement is completed over the crossing, the signals shall again be set clear for train movements on the Ann Arbor and at block against train movements on the New York Central. Attached to said application is a copy of a letter dated July 16, 1932 addressed to V. Parvin, General Superintendent of the Ann Arbor Rail road Company and signed by E. W. Brown, Superintendent of the New York Central Railroad Company advising that his company is agreeable to the discontinuance of the towerman and to the operation of the signals by a member of their train crew when a movement is to be made over the crossing. -

The Commission on the 2nd day of August, 1932 caused notice of hearing in said matter to be mailed to the parties in interest, including E. F. Cowley, Vice-President of the Order of Railroad Telegraphers, which hearing was held in the offices of the Commission in the City of Lansing on the 12th day of August, 1932.

The Commission after due consideration of the evidence as submitted at said hearing, being advised of the few train movements over the cross ing and the agreement as to the method of operating trains, has concluded that the safety of the traveling public will not be jeopardized by the discontinuance of the towerman at said crossing; provided the normal position of the signals governing the approach of trains to the crossing are set clear for all train movements on the Ann Arbor and at block against train movements on the New York Central and in case of a train movement on the New York Central over the crossing, one of the train crew will go to the tower in advance of said movement and operate the signals to set up the route for their train movement and at block for train movements on the Ann Arbor, and after said train has passed over the crossing, he will again set the signals at block against train movements on his company's railroad and clear for train movements on the Ann Arbor.

THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, By the Michigan Public Utilities Commission that permission be, and the same is hereby granted to the Ann Arbor Railroad Company to discontinue the towerman as now maintained at the crossing of its tracks and the tracks of the New York Central Railroad Company at Federman; Provided, that the signals governing the approach of all train movements on the Ann Arbor Rail road are set normally clear and at block against train movements on the New York Central Railroad and in case of any train movement over the crossing on the tracks of the New York Central Railroad, a member of the train crew shall go to the tower in advance of such movement and after satisfying himself that there are no trains on the Ann Arbor tracks in the immediate vicinity about to cross over the crossing, shall then and then only set the signals clear for train movements on the New York Central over the crossing and at block against train movements on the Ann Arbor, and after his company's train has passed over the crossing, he shall again set the signals in their normal position of at block against train movements on the New York Central and clear for train movements on the Ann Arbor. MICHIGAN PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION

In re: Application of Walter S. Franklin and Frank C. Nicodemus, Jr., as Receivers of The Ann Arbor Railroad Company for authority to discontinue the station at Lake George, Clare County, as an agency station and to make the same a regular prepay station. D-2742. November 3, 1932.

Petition having been filed with the Michigan Public Utilities Com mission by Walter S. Franklin and Frank C. Nicodemus, Jr., as Receivers of The Ann Arbor Railroad Company for authority to discontinue Lake George station on the Ann Arbor Railroad as an agency station and to make the same a regular prepay station for the reason that the expense of operating this station is far in excess of the earnings.

After due notice to all parties in interest this matter was brought on for hearing before the Michigan Public Utilities Commission at its offices in the City of Lansing. -

The Commission, after due consideration of the evidence as submitted, and being advised therein that the ratio of station expense to revenues, both freight and passenger, for the year 1929 was 145.3%, for 1930 was 220.5%, and for 1931 was 226.1%, has concluded that such earnings are not sufficient to warrant the maintaining of Lake George as a regular agency station at the present time, and is of the opinion that the public will be reasonably and adequately served by the discontinuing of Lake George as a regular agency station and to continue the same as a non-agency prepay station until such time as traffic at said station increases to such an extent as to justify, in the opinion of the Commission, the expense and require the services of an agent.

THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, By the Michigan Public Utilities Commission, That Walter S. Franklin and Frank C. Nicodemus, Jr., . Receivers of The Ann Arbor Railroad Company be, and they are here by authorized and empowered to discontinue Lake George station in Clare County on the Ann Arbor Railroad as an agency station, provided, the same be continued as a non-agency station until such time as traffic at such station justifies the expense and services of a regular station agent.

MICH IGAN PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION.

In re: Application of Walter S. Franklin and Frank C. Nicodemus, Jr., as Receivers of the Ann Arbor Railroad Company for authority to close Oak Grove station on the Ann Arbor Railroad as an agency station and make same a prepay station. D-2743. November 3, 1932

Petition having been filed with the Michigan Public Utilities Com mission by Walter S. Franklin and Frank C. Nicodemus, Jr., Receivers of The Ann Arbor Railroad Company for authority to close Oak Grove station on the Ann Arbor Railroad as an agency station and to make same a prepay station for the reason that the earnings are not sufficient to warrant the maintaining of said station as an agency station.

After due notice to all parties in interest this matter was brought on for hearing before the Michigan Public Utilities Commission at its offices in the City of Lansing.

The Commission, after due consideration of the evidence as submitted, and being advised therein that the ratio of station expenses to revenues, both freight and passenger, for the year 1929 was 49.6%, for 1930 was 204.9%, for 1931 was 207.9%, has concluded that such earnings are not sufficient to warrant the maintaining of Oak Grove as a regular agency station at the present time and is of the opinion that the public will be reasonably and adequately served by discontinuing Oak Grove as a regular agency station and make same a non-agency prepay station until such time as traffic at such station increases to such an extent as to justify, in the opinion of the Commission, the expense and require the services of an agent.

THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, By the Michigan Public Utilities Commission, That Walter S. Franklin and Frank C. Nicodemus, Jr., Receivers of The Ann Arbor Railroad Company, be and they are hereby authorized and empowered to discontinue Oak Grove station on the Ann Arbor Railroad as an agency station, provided, the same be continued as a non-agency prepay station until such time as traffic at such station justifies the expense and services of a regular station agent. MICHIGAN PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION.

In the matter of the application of The Ann Arbor Railroad Company for authority to close its station at Carland as an agency station.

In the matter of the petition of the Citizens of Carland asking that The Ann Arbor Railroad Company build a new depot and freight house at Carland. D-2533. November 4, 1932

and further, the business transacted at Carland is not sufficient to justify the employment of an agent at that station. After due notice to all parties in interest this matter was brought on for hearing before the Michigan Public Utilities Commission at its offices in the City of Lansing. The Commission, after due consideration of the evidence as submitted and being advised therein that the average rate per month of station expenses to revenues, both freight and passenger, for the year 1931 was 40.7%, and for 1932, 38.0%, has concluded that such earnings are not sufficient to warrant the maintaining of Carland as a regular agency station at the present time and is of the opinion that the public will be reasonably and adequately served by the discontinuing of Carland as a regular agency station until such time as traffic at such station increases to such an extent as to justify, in the opinion of the Commission, the expense and require the services of an agent, provided, a care taker shall be maintained in place of said station agent, and has further concluded, that the request of the railroad company for a twelve month extension of time from date hereof within which to construct the new building at said station be granted. THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, By the Michigan Public Utilities Commission, That its order of August 7th, 1931, in the above proceedings, be modified to read as follows :

Walter S. Franklin and Frank C. Nicodemus, Jr., Receivers of The Ann Arbor Railroad Company, be and they are hereby authorized and empowered to discontinue Carland station on the Ann Arbor Railroad as an agency station until such time as traffic at such station justifies the expense and services of a regular station agent; provided,

  1. That said station be continued as a non-agency station in charge of a caretaker who shall keep the depot buildings clean, well lighted and warm for the accommodation of the traveling pub lic and also to properly care for freight and deliver same to patrons until the further order of this Commission.

  2. That within twelve months from date of this order that you cause to be erected and thereafter maintained a new building at said station with facilities for the accommodation of passengers and the delivering and receiving of L.C.L. freight and similar shipments. MICHIGAN PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION.

In the matter of the application of Walter S. Franklin and Frank C. Nicodemus, Jr., Receivers of The Ann Arbor Railroad Company for the approval of wigwag and flash light signals as now maintained at the West Main Street and Corunna Avenue crossings of the Ann Arbor Railroad in Owosso. D-2761. December 9, 1932.

Petition having been filed with this Commission in the above entitled matter by the Receivers of the Ann Arbor Railroad requesting the ap proval of the signals as now maintained to warn traffic on West Main Street and Corunna Avenue crossings of the tracks of The Ann Arbor Railroad in Owosso of the approach of engines and trains on the main line, which signals were installed by the Ann Arbor Railroad Company without an order of this Commission, and request is now made for approval of such signals by an order of this Commission. -

After due notice to all parties in interest this matter was brought on for hearing before the Michigan Public Utilities Commission at its offices in the City of Lansing.

The Commission after due consideration of the evidence as submitted has concluded that the said signals afford reasonable warning to traffic on West Main Street and Corunna Avenue crossings of the Ann Arbor Railroad of the approach of engines and trains on the main line, there fore, the request should be granted. THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, By the Michigan Public Utilities Commission, That Walter S. Franklin and Frank C. Nicodemus, Jr., Receivers of the Ann Arbor Railroad, be and they are hereby authorized and empowered, until the further order of this Commission, to continue the wig wag and flashlight signals as now maintained at the West Main Street and Corunna Avenue crossings of the Ann Arbor Railroad in the City of Owosso to warn traffic of the approach of engines and trains on the main line of the Ann Arbor Railroad, which signals are hereby approved for immediate use; provided,

  1. That, if at any time said signals become inoperative, that you cause a watchman to be immediately stationed at the crossing or crossings so affected to warn traffic of the approach of engines and trains until said signals have been restored to working order.

  2. That in case of any switch movements over said crossings, that you require a member of the train crew making such movements to guard the crossing or crossings warning traffic in advance of such movements.

MICHIGAN PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION.